BuyCrypt
BuyCrypt · Guide

Why Do Many Traders Fail on Prop Challenges?

Successful completion of a prop challenge isn’t impossible; BuyCrypt has a track record of issuing $384K through 124 funded accounts and 48 tournaments conducted to date. However, when you look at why participants do not succeed on the challenges, it’s not the lack of having a system that causes them to fail; it’s normally because they make a few recurrent behavioral errors, which we can find in data time and time again. There are five common behavioral reasons that result in traders failing the challenges; find below the solutions for each of them and learn how to perfect them before starting any real evaluation. (BuyCrypt does not involve betting, and it is skill-based trading simulation in nature; results vary and earnings are not guaranteed).

What passing a prop challenge means, and why it is a discipline test rather than a strategy test

One passes a prop challenge in order to get sponsored. The proposition is simple; the company is interested in whether you can produce profit without exceeding the allowable drawdown limit. The rephrasing is vital because it explains why even the most skilled traders could fail in the evaluation process; they optimize for a wrong parameter (being right) when in fact the challenge pays the most for staying within bounds while being right often enough.

People who successfully pass thus rarely show off their best-executed trade but rather have a combination of winning trades with none of them exposing them to more damage than necessary. It means that behavioral reasons stand at the heart of prop traders’ failure.

So, there is no need to worry about ‘bad charting’ you will find below for your review. Every single failure is based on behavioral decisions taken under stress, and each one can be practiced in advance.

Common failure 1: Going too big when trying to reach the objective fast

The main reason behind failure is related to over-leveraging. It happens when a trader sees a defined profit level (e.g. 8%) and thinks that if he/she makes two very large trades with high leverage, he/she will succeed very quickly. The logic behind the conclusion sounds appealing, but it ignores a fact that the leverage used to accomplish success in two trades can devastate account value in one single trade.

Over-leveraging translates normal noise on the market into disasters for traders/companies involved in prop trading. If the size of the trade is the one enabling a 2% negative change to clear 6% of the account value, there is no way for the person to get back up, even if the underlying trade idea is a sound one.

The solution implies choosing an amount to lose (normally 0.5%-1% of the total account value) before measuring success. Use BuyCrypt’s demo tournament to practice this approach!

Common failure 2: Trying to trade back the loss

Sorry for being rude, but revenge trading only harms. After losing, a trader feels emotionally hurt and wants to make a new trade based on the previous loss in significance. This kind of trades usually loses more and more. You can figure out whether you are just making mistakes or still being able to rationalize things.

The solution includes immediate action stop for at least 30 minutes after a failed trade(s) to avoid making another one.

Common failure 3: Not following the daily loss limit

It is often the case that prop trading challenges have defined limits/constraints such as drawdown/losing limits (daily and overall throughout the challenge).

Learn how to monitor the daily result throughout the day, and do not forget about checking the limit.

Common failure 4: Ignoring news trading and other events

Major events such as employment data releases, interest rates, unlocking cryptocurrency tokens and so forth bring about volatility which traders consider as a chance for earning money with certainty, but actually yields just the opposite since it leads to losses. News trading without any preparations cannot work.

Common failure 5: Treating evaluations like casino games

Last, but not least reason that connects all above-mentioned reasons includes inappropriate beliefs/ideas about prop trading challenges treating the process as a game of chance instead of skill acquisition.

A tell of variance-seeking characterizes gambling behavior. The gambler desires the most substantial variation available, as their perception is that it will yield a single hit. Conversely, the trader looks for the least swing, which continues providing compound gains; the cumulative effect of many trades constitutes the trader's gains. The prop trader pass rate (which frequently operates on a 50% pass rate basis for all qualified traders) rewards the trader who maintains many more smaller trades than the variance-seeking trader.

You can run your challenge as an operation; therefore, unless you are following a predefined protocol (in terms of set rules, specified risk, pre-written instructions or guidelines, and reviewing everything you have done), you cannot really call your prop challenge a very effective exercise. Whenever you follow BuyCrypt's tournament loop approach, you do not need to make any cash deposits; that is how you can successfully run the $5000 evaluation and follow up on it with one single tournament after having received a solid answer.

How to rehearse before you pay for a real challenge

There is a rehearsal plan that involves running the full length evaluation in which you pay utmost attention to the positional adjustments that you make. For the repetition of the evaluation scheme, you should evaluate how closely you adhered to the rules of the game.

Discipline pays. You can learn that discipline does pay when seeing the aggregate results.

FAQ

What are the primary reasons that traders fail prop challenges?

The common reason that results in the breach of a limit is over-leveraging. Although the primary goal is to get to the evaluation as rapidly as possible.

Am I able to recover from losing trades?

Many times you can still do so unless you do not exceed the limits you established for your evaluation. In case of excessive loss, the action to be taken should be the following: stop trading for some time.

Must I trade all days during evaluations?

Actually, you are not necessarily able to do so.

How do demo tournaments aid me in passing these evaluations?

Demo tournaments provide necessary emotions without having to pay an evaluation fee.

Is the prop trading similar to gambling?

No. While playing at a roulette table, players depend on luck to make their fortune.

What distinguishes daily drawdown from the overall drawdown?

The daily drawdown is the maximum loss you are able to incur during 1 day, while the overall drawdown indicates the maximum amount of losses you can incur trying to pass your evaluation.